First time Wincest / pining & thresomes

[infinitefeels.livejournal.com]

I'm looking for any first time Sam/Dean that starts out as them with other girls or threesomes (reluctant or not) and then getting together.

Bonus for pining, jealousy, and angst plus happy ending! :)

EDIT: Compiled Recs Below

- Fray  jaimeykay:  Jeff and Jensen have been married for several years. Abused by a past lover, Jensen struggles with self-doubt. When Jeff introduces a co-worker, Jared, Jensen wonders what will happen to his marriage. (Jensen/JDM/Jared, Past!Jensen/Abusive Ex) *See Specific rec for this prompt: (multiple fills) here.

- Ghost of a Long Ago Kiss - sn_fic: Sam’s senior year of high school was memorable for a double date with Dean and the Jones sisters. Ten years later, they are unexpectedly reunited, sparking memories of what happened that night at Lookout Point that Dean and Sam have been avoiding ever since.

- Higher Learning - destina: Sam/Dean, Sam/Dean/OFC, adult themespre-series (Stanford), about 5100 wds
- Like Staring Into the Sun - nyxocity: It’s not about the girls. The girls are just the excuse. It’s about them. Them and this unavoidable thing that’s growing between them.

- O Come All Ye Faithful - Dollylux: Sam Wesson hates Christmas office parties. Well, until this one of course. (Swesson!)Day One of my fic advent calendar. Prompt: office parties. (Sam/Dean/OFC) - mostly Sam/Dean

- One Night Wonders - kinksock22:  For this prompt at the kink meme: Just what it says. Sam and Dean's experience with Heather was apparently quite memorable--I want to know all about it. I want a long, satisfying night with both Dean and Sam having sex with Heather and making it clear that they are into each other as well. I want Heather to be okay with them and maybe even get off on it. oral sex, rimming, anal sex, blowjobs, dp--the whole nine yards, please!

- Push Comes to Shove - t_fic (topaz), topaz, topaz119 (topaz):They're Winchesters--they're good at making sure that not dealing with things doesn't slow them down, and mostly, just doing the job is enough to let them not think about a lot of stuff. But some jobs are worse than others, and even a little time off isn't going to fix things after you let them go long enough.
- Resemblance to Sense - BewareTheIdes15: Sam is never telling Dean anything ever again. He’s not even sure why he ever told him anything before. Not that he actually told Dean about this so much as he just didn’t deny it when Dean accused. Any which way, though, dying a virgin would be better than having Dean trying to pimp him out to every girl in a ten mile radius.

* The Ballad of the Invisible Boy - Dollylux: This is a story of adolescence. This is a love letter for the slow burn, for Led Zeppelin, for the 90s. This is the first of two sets of stories about how Sam and Dean didn’t fall in love. They never had to. It was always there, this desperation between them, like a real, breathing thing. When they came together, it was inevitable. As sure as continents colliding, as the phases of the moon and the life and death of stars. This isn’t a love story, but it’s a story of love. (Dean/OFC(s), Sam/OFC, etc.)

- Trifecta - setissma: Trifecta, Sam/Dean, Sam/Dean + Jo, Sam/Dean/OFCs plus various permutations thereof, 5050 words, NC-17.

- You and Me and Sammy Makes Three - JustineDelarge:  Remember when Sammy confessed his fantasy of having a three-way with Dean and Dean? Here it is.

If anyone checks back, I'm continuing to rec this plot on my tumblr here: http://wincestrec.tumblr.com/post/156925102868/threesome-samdeanofc

Comments

[flawedteacup.livejournal.com]

Try nyxocity's Like Staring Into The Sun. (http://nyxocity.livejournal.com/149120.html)

[citrusjava.livejournal.com]

The Air Moves in to Fill the Spaces Where My Body's Been & The Frightened Inch Between Our Skins by Britomart_is, and Trifecta by Setissma, and Higher Learningby Destia - and all have lovely podfics by Applegeuse, by the way!
There is some Wincestiel for that trope if you like too

[adameyezd.livejournal.com]

Don't suppose you have links to Trifecta & Higher Learning?

Thanks for these recs.

[margaret27new.livejournal.com]

http://setissma.livejournal.com/553050.html Trifecta

[adameyezd.livejournal.com]

Well thank you very much for the Trifecta link! I copied it & it looks really good!

Thank you for your kindness in sharing!

[margaret27new.livejournal.com]

http://destina.livejournal.com/363746.html

[adameyezd.livejournal.com]

Wow, looks like I just got a duo-fecta! Heh-heh. Ok, not funny.

But anyway, thank you for the link to Higher Learning too! I just copied/pasted it.

Double-thanks for taking the time to share both links. I really appreciate it!!

[margaret27new.livejournal.com]

http://archiveofourown.org/works/318886
One of my absolute favorites.

[chellexxx.livejournal.com]

There are a few here (https://delicious.com/chellexxx1/Sam%2FDean%2Fofc,First!Time) you might like

xxx

[karala.livejournal.com]

In The Ballad of the Invisible Boy by dollylux Sam's first sexual experience is with a girl while Dean is with another girl in the same room. Pretty hot scene. Very very veeeeeeeery long fic.

[infinitefeels.livejournal.com]

That's actually the one I had in mind at the time! So lovely. It's my favorite fic! :D Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Ok well as it happens I just read abother one.

Push Comes to Shove
http://archiveofourown.org/works/116042?view_full_work=true

I know I have read a number more but can't think of them.

[(Anonymous)]

And here is another:
Ghost of a Long Ago Kiss by runedgirl